Is There A Difference Between Nyjer And Thistle Seed?

When it comes to bird feeding, the terms Nyjer and thistle seed are often used interchangeably. However, it’s essential to understand that there is a distinct difference between the two. Let’s delve into the nuances of Nyjer and thistle seed and uncover what sets them apart.

What is Nyjer Seed?

Nyjer seed, scientifically known as Guizotia abyssinica, is a small, oil-rich seed that is popular among finches, especially goldfinches and siskins. The tiny black seeds have a high oil content, making them a nutritious and energy-rich food source for birds.

Clarifying Thistle Seed

Thistle seed, on the other hand, refers to the seeds of plants belonging to the Asteraceae family, commonly known as thistles. These seeds are not typically preferred by birds and are often considered a nuisance by gardeners due to their invasive nature.

The Myth of Thistle Seed

Interestingly, Nyjer seed is often misrepresented and sold as thistle seed. This mislabeling can lead to confusion among bird enthusiasts who are unaware of the differences between the two types of seeds.

Trademarking Nyjer Seed

To address this confusion, the Wild Bird Feeding Institute took a proactive step by trademarking the seed as Nyjer in 1998. This trademark helps distinguish the genuine Nyjer seed from other seeds falsely marketed as thistle seed.

Nutritional Value of Nyjer Seed

Nyjer seed stands out for its high oil content, rich in essential nutrients that benefit birds, particularly during the demanding winter months. Its nutritional profile makes it a sought-after food choice for many bird species.

Benefits of Offering Nyjer Seed

By providing Nyjer seed in bird feeders, you can attract a diverse array of finches and other small songbirds to your backyard. These birds will not only enjoy the tasty treat but also benefit from the energy boost it provides.

Growth of Thistle Plants

Thistle plants, on the contrary, are known for their invasive growth tendencies and are often considered weeds. Despite their name association with birdseed, thistle plants may not necessarily offer the same nutritional benefits as Nyjer seed.

Quality Assurance with Nyjer Seed

Due to the trademarking of Nyjer seed, consumers can have confidence in the quality and authenticity of the seed they are purchasing for their feathered friends. This assurance ensures that birds receive the best possible nutrition.

Differentiating Nyjer and Thistle Seed

While Nyjer seed and thistle seed may share some similarities in appearance, their botanical origins and nutritional compositions are distinct. Understanding these differences can help bird enthusiasts make informed choices when selecting bird feed for their backyard visitors.

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, Nyjer seed and thistle seed are not the same, despite common misconceptions. By recognizing the unique qualities of Nyjer seed and understanding the reasons behind its trademarking, bird lovers can provide their avian companions with a high-quality and nutritionally beneficial food source.

Photo of author

Don Atkins

Don Atkins is a proud Canadian and experienced biology teacher living in Toronto. With a Bachelor of Science in Biology from the University of Saskatchewan under his belt, Don has 10 years of teaching experience and is passionate about sharing his knowledge with others. He also volunteers at the Northeastern Avian Rescue, using his expertise to help birds in need. Don's enthusiasm for ornithology is undeniable, and he loves nothing more than to share it with those around him.