What Birds Look Like Cardinals But Are Not?

When it comes to birds that share a resemblance with cardinals but are entirely distinct species, there are a few noteworthy examples to explore. These avian creatures may exhibit similar physical characteristics or coloration patterns, leading to potential confusion among bird enthusiasts and observers.

Scarlet Tanager

One such bird that often gets mistaken for a cardinal is the Scarlet Tanager. With its vibrant red body and contrasting black wings, this species bears a striking resemblance to the iconic northern cardinal. However, upon closer examination, one can differentiate between the two based on the Scarlet Tanager’s slender shape and different beak structure.

Summer Tanager

Another bird species that shares similarities with cardinals is the Summer Tanager. Sporting a bright red plumage similar to that of the cardinal, the Summer Tanager can be easily mistaken for its look-alike counterpart. Nevertheless, subtle differences in body size and overall color intensity can help in distinguishing between the two species.

Vermilion Flycatcher

The Vermilion Flycatcher is yet another avian creature that can be confused with cardinals due to its fiery red appearance. Despite their resemblances, particularly in terms of coloration, these birds differ significantly in terms of behavior and habitat preferences. The Vermilion Flycatcher is a remarkable sight in the wild, showcasing its unique beauty.

Crimson Rosella

For bird enthusiasts in Australia, the Crimson Rosella might evoke thoughts of the cardinal due to its red plumage and captivating presence. While reminiscent in color, these two species belong to different continents and have distinct features that set them apart. The Crimson Rosella is a delightful sight in its native habitat.

Black-headed Grosbeak

The Black-headed Grosbeak, predominantly found in western North America, is another bird species that can be mistaken for a cardinal, mainly due to its red and black color scheme. However, the Black-headed Grosbeak possesses distinct markings and physical characteristics that differentiate it from its cardinal counterpart.

Western Tanager

Lastly, the Western Tanager is a bird species known for its vibrant red plumage and yellow accents, often leading to comparisons with the cardinal. While sharing certain color resemblances, the Western Tanager boasts a unique appearance and behavior that distinguishes it from the classic northern cardinal.

Photo of author

Don Atkins

Don Atkins is a proud Canadian and experienced biology teacher living in Toronto. With a Bachelor of Science in Biology from the University of Saskatchewan under his belt, Don has 10 years of teaching experience and is passionate about sharing his knowledge with others. He also volunteers at the Northeastern Avian Rescue, using his expertise to help birds in need. Don's enthusiasm for ornithology is undeniable, and he loves nothing more than to share it with those around him.